“You know how many hits I got?” The genius at work on his keyboards/samplers toward the end of his initial set (in the midst of a freestyle mix/onslaught of some of the best pop hits of my generation – “When Doves Cry”/”Nasty Girl”/”Sign ☮ the Times”/”Pop Life”/”If I Was Your Girlfriend”/”Housequake”/”I Would Die For You”/etc…). All culminating in a mind blowing rendition of “Purple Rain” (in which Prince made a comment about how he will never get tired of that song). I don’t know if it was just a fantastic audience at the Fox Theater last night, or if Prince simply had the power to bring us to life and in perfect unison with his music, but this one off, last minute (instant sell out) show was certainly one I won’t forget. I’ve never seen the Fox that rocking before (and I’ve seen many shows there) and I would even go so far as to say last night’s show blew away his set of shows played at the relatively tiny DNA Lounge last year (see review Night #1, Night #2). As epic as those were (and I counted the two I went to among the very best of the nearly 100 concerts I attended last year), this one bested them on nearly every level. Truly a musical genius at work alongside the brilliant 3RDEYEGIRL, as though they came down from some other planet for a few hours to illustrate another way of life. Words really can’t describe, and without photos to aid in retelling the experience, it was really something you would have had to have been there for to fully appreciate and understand.
Who: Prince with 3RDEYEGIRL
Supporting: LiV Warfield with NPG Hornz and Blackbird
Venue: Fox Theater Oakland
Where: Oakland, California
Promoter: Another Planet Entertainment
When: March 15, 2014
Seating: General Admission Standing (Front Row Center on Second Elevated Floor Section on Rail)
NO PHOTO / VIDEO POLICY
Any Prince show is really an event, and with a few shows played in England and recently L.A., it was both a surprise and kind of not as much, really, when a rumor caught on fire this past Wednesday that he and 3RDEYEGIRL might be coming to Fox Theater in Oakland, courtesy Another Planet Entertainment.
Less than an hour after hearing this rumor, I reached out to my contact at the promoter, and nearly as quick they sent an e-mail out to their subscribers with a link to Ticketmaster for tickets to the sale, which were to go on sale just 9 minutes later (at the unusual time of 10:30 PM). Unfortunately, that link ended up being to a dead page, but by the time I figured that out, the show had sold out! Maybe a half an hour past that sale time, I did manage to get a single ticket through the Live Nation iPhone app, and then a second, so I was thrilled to have an opportunity to see Prince as well as to take my girlfriend to see him (she never had, and funny enough we’ve talked about it a lot recently, so it was serendipitous).
I’ve actually been dragging with a flu/cold this week, so Prince is one of a handful of artists I would drag myself to (with the 3 hour drive each way into the Bay Area) while feeling pretty fatigued. Of course, it was completely worth it.
My buddy Nick actually arrived at the venue at 10:00 AM, and was about 30th in line at that point. He described it as “the best concert line ever”. There was even an organized flash mob.
When my girlfriend and I arrived and parked in the lot behind the venue, we couldn’t help but laugh at Bay Alarm Company’s billboard, which had been plastered over with Prince’s image and a “Welcome to Oakland” sign, leaving just their slogan, “IT’S LIKE YOU NEVER LEFT”.
What a better marquee to see outside a venue than this?
In any event, with their no press photography/no fan photography policy, I respected that request (as I did with the DNA Lounge shows in San Francisco last year), so that is where my photography begins and ends with this review.
Things were pretty consistently on schedule, with doors opening at 8:00 for the 9:00 show.
As mentioned, I have been under the weather, so opted for the second level on the floor, which is elevated and fronted with a rail, so I had an awesome perspective for the show (in sights and sounds), peering over the main fans on the floor below, just short of level with the stage. Plus you get that thrill from seeing a packed crowd of fans with their hands in the air, backlit from the array of lights coming from the stage.
Unlike the concert dates last year, Prince and 3RDEYEGIRL had a supporting show last night, fronted by LiV Warfield.
LiV Warfield is an amazing R&B and soul singer, and she put on a powerful set in the span of about a half an hour to get the place jumping in anticipation of the main show. She and her cohorts packed an incredible amount of music into that 30 minute slot, with material off her new album, The Unexpected.
Flanked by an incredible band, including the NPG Hornz and Blackbird, it was a stellar show in it’s own right, and all involved returned to the stage later during Prince’s multiple encores to finish out the (late) evening.
Once the opening set wrapped and after a 30 minute or so intermission, the women of 3RDEYEGIRL came onto the stage to welcome the audience, tell us that they were about to put on “the best show you’ve ever seen”, and put a reminder out about the no photo/video/cell phone policy. There were also extra staffers on the floor prepared to eject anyone who violated this request, but in the many hours that the show ran, I never saw anyone sneak a photo of any kind.
3RDEYEGIRL are amazing artists – Prince really knows how to identify real talent – and is comprised of Donna Grantis (guitar), Ida Nielsen (bass), and Hannah Ford (drums).
The funny thing is my friend asked me what I thought they might open with, to which I guess “Let’s Go Crazy” (and he countered sarcastically with his guess of “some obscure B-side from 1995”), and funny enough, I ended up being right, with a rearranged version burning on the stage.
A few songs later, Prince proclaimed, “let’s take the Bay Area back to 1982” and kicked into a playful version of “She’s Always in My Hair”.
I tried to keep track of the set list as it went along, but eventually gave up as I wanted to really be in the moment of the show, and so below is the record of the show per Setlist.fm as of the time I am writing this article…
Setlist:
- Fallinlove2nite
- Let’s Go Crazy (Blues style, w/interp of Edgar Winter’s Frankenstein)
- Funknroll
- She’s Always in My Hair
- I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man
- The Ocean (Led Zeppelin cover) (Instrumental, segue into … )
- Guitar
- Plectrum Electrum
- FixUrLifeUp
- Something in the Water (Does Not Compute)
- When Doves Cry (Partial)
- Nasty Girl (Vanity 6 cover) (Sample)
- Sign “☮” the Times (Partial)
- 777-9311 (The Time cover) (Sample)
- Forever in My Life
- Pop Life (Partial)
- Love (Sample)
- If I Was Your Girlfriend (Partial)
- The Screams of Passion (The Family cover) (Sample)
- Housequake (Partial)
- I Would Die 4 U (Partial)
- Purple Rain
Encore:
- U Got the Look (With LiV Warfield on co-lead vox)
- Musicology (With LiV Warfield and NPG horns)
- Play That Funky Music (Wild Cherry cover) (With LiV Warfield and NPG horns)
Encore 2:
- How Come U Don’t Call Me Anymore
- Diamonds and Pearls
- The Beautiful Ones
- Strange Relationship
- Starfish and Coffee
- Do Me, Baby
- I Wanna Be Your Lover
- Hot Thing (Partial, with NPG horns)
- A Love Bizarre (Sheila E. cover) (Partial, with NPG horns)
- Mr. Goodnight (Sample, with NPG horns)
- Raspberry Beret (With NPG horns)
- Cool (The Time cover) (With NPG horns and audience members dancing on stage)
- Funknroll
While I wrote really lengthy reviews with my thoughts on the two Prince shows I attended last year, I really don’t even know how to properly approach a recap of his concerts, as words really can’t do them justice, apart from going on and on about how much of a genius the man is in his artistry, his work, and his ability to bring it all alive on stage. Quite honestly, I don’t believe that there is an artist in music today that can really come close to matching what Prince does in his performances. I’ve never seen such a gifted musician perform live. Period.
He seems to have somehow figured out how to curb the aging process since he became a huge star in the early 80s, as he looks (and acts) incredibly youthful. One of the most fun bits from last night was when his put his guitar on its stand with some real purpose, and broke out with some killer dance moves for quite a while, donging the bottoms of his pink bell bottoms, as if his feet were the clappers.
The man is just beaming with joy and good will as he performs – you can tell he loves it, and with his eyes locking onto fans’ own transfixed gazes all around the venue, he wants to desperately share in this and bring you along for the ride.
The lighting was superb, and kudos to the lighting tech(s) who run these shows, as the timing and connection with every little nuance of what is going on with the action on stage (and seemingly thoughts in Prince’s mind) is uncanny. Unless somehow Prince has himself learned how to operate the lights himself via sheer force of will or maybe through some otherworldly mind control.
Like how I felt with last year’s shows, overall it felt like a loosely framed jam session, and I mean that in the most complimentary way possible. There is so much (seeming) improvisation and spontaneity that there is a sense that anything can happen, and any song (new, old, or invented on the fly) could break out into the performance. Like I described last year, it seems to be a perfect collision of the planned and unplanned – true genius and artistry at work.
He engages the audience unlike any artist I’ve ever seen. He truly feeds the audience, and then sucks that energy back out. He seems to see a collective but also a sea of individuals. His eyes seek out yours, and each smile, nod, wry expression, look of faux surprise, pointing of his finger… he’s sharing in his greatness on stage with everyone there for the show.
And the expressions on his face… he is living his music. As much brilliance comes out of his guitar, it’s almost like the guitar isn’t up to the task of keeping up with him, and this energy is just coming from his face, like there is all of this music within him and as much as we hear it and see it, it is an endless reservoir of brilliance that can’t burst out of him adequately enough.
As always, Prince loves to share his stage with fellow artists, and give each of them moments to shine. Last night, one of the highlights was the succession of horn section players having their moments center stage, like some private party unfolding before the packed audience of nearly 3,000 fans. And at another point in one of the encores (for which I lost count), Prince had fans brought up on stage to dance for what seemed like forever. One of my favorite encore songs was “U Got The Look” with LiV Warfield taking over the female vocals. Amazing.
But like his shows, which never seem to end, nor does his ambition to create new music. Their upcoming album, Plectrum Electrum, is expected this year, so it will be interesting to see how additional live shows are planned (or spontaneously pop up, like this one did this week).
Prince could obviously sell out stadiums all over the world with super high ticket prices, but as with everything, he has a unique approach to sharing his art. I, for one, really respect that he is playing these more intimate venues and creating special and unique experiences with fans, rather than merely cashing in on the past. In any event, it was a brilliant night, and I wish I had the gift to better recount what it was like, but maybe that is the point… to truly understand and appreciate, I think you need to be fortunate enough to attend one of his shows yourself to truly witness his gifts and artistry. The top “must see” act of several generations, in my opinion. Toward the end of the night, Prince continuously pledged that the Bay Area will see him again, “sooner than you think“, so hopefully another visit to planet Earth is in the works.
Jason DeBord
You are a brilliant writer and truly love prince as do I and others. Yes, he does live hisusic and as a fan u want all of that energy. He makes one feel alive inspired and in a secret free society of like minded purple souls. This is the best prince concert review ive ever read.
Thanks for the kind words – it is much appreciated.
Honestly, it would be nice if world leaders could all be collected up and subjected to a full on Prince concert… maybe it would change their perspectives for the better!
Jason
Agreed!
I stood in front of this reviewer near the end (saw him taking notes). Here’s another perspective:
Liv Warfield was a very good singer, but was a surprising choice for a protégé. I suspect that there are scores of women who could sing similarly, and perhaps the catch to opening for Prince is to _not_ outperform him.
The sound at the Fox was horrible. Far too loud, and a muddy and unlistenable mix. Too loud to forego earplugs, which is unnecessary and means you can’t really appreciate musicianship. (I once saw Genesis and you could pick out the sound through the mix of Collins picking up his tambourine.) A couple stood next to us during the encores: “We paid $500 for seats in the mezzanine and we can’t hear a thing there!”
And Prince, bless his heart, was simply going through the motions most of the time. He spent an extended part of the first set simply triggering different samples on his keyboard and singing a few bars. Then he’d change samples and sing a few more. No rhythm; no segue; no real plan. And yet I paid about $250 for my wife and I to stand there while he figured out what he wanted to do. He couldn’t even be considerate about the end – after leaving the stage and the cheering fans, there was no definitive “we’re done” for about a half an hour, and then the load out began in bits and pieces. It was a disappointing end for the fans, and felt inconsiderate. Some of us had to get up early, and would’ve appreciated not standing there for a half hour for no reason.
Disclaimer: I’ve been a fan since “For You,” and have seen him repeatedly. He’s the only musician whose output makes me LOL at its creativity. I still expect great things from him. But you can’t get me to spend big bucks on a show if it’s going to be this unremarkable. That’s just a fact of life.
Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts; it is appreciated.
Everything with music is pretty subjective, and obviously we came away with completely different experiences, and I certainly wouldn’t argue one over the other – it is what it is.
I did intend to mention that I thought that the low frequency was coming out too strong… but I do have quality ear plugs that compensate for that, and there is definitely variances within the Fox depending on where you are and other factors. Also, I thought that the keyboard/sampler bits sounded superior to the more rocking bits, and actually pulled out my ear plugs for those moments.
Yes, after the (I think) third encore, and Prince and 3RDEYEGIRL came out and bowed, and the house lights came up, and a roadie came out and tossed drumsticks into the crowd, and house music came on… I took that as a clear cue that the show was over, though a good percentage of the audience (at least 70%) stayed… maybe they were awestruck, maybe they hoped it would never end, but I figured that was it and hit the road. Having said all that, my friend were convinced more would come… again, I guess it is subjective.
Obviously I raved about the show and stand by that, but respect any differences of opinions.
Jason
I think it’s a shame that going to a concert means you have to wear earplugs. When I saw Dylan a few years ago, the openers (Kings of Leon) were so devastatingly loud – in the lobby! – that I had no intention of going into the auditorium, even though I was really interested in seeing them.
Alas, I wish things were more subtle. Certainly there’s a middle ground between inaudible and intolerable.
And get off my lawn, you kids!
Ferris – I can’t comment on the sound because I wasn’t there but seriously, who pays to sit at a Prince gig unless you are disabled or pregnant? As for earplugs – wow. Has to be medical otherwise its like asking for lemonade with your Bordeux
Earplugs are a an unfortunate must at concerts those days. Believe me, I know, I “broke” my ears and must live with tinitus and hyperacousie since I went to a Prince concert in Paris… 12 years ago.
Yeah, I go to upwards of 100 shows a year, and shoot at least the first three songs of most of them (usually with a big speaker a few feet to a few inches from my head)… and at smaller shows am up in front for the duration, so earplugs are a must for me.
But every show is different, and sometimes they are not necessary. In any event, there are affordable, quality, musician’s earplugs that in some cases improve the sound, as they even things out and you hear the full range just turned down slightly.
I can’t tell you how many people I run into that work in music that have hearing loss and/or damage. There’s a reason Oingo Boingo called it back in ’95!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danny_Elfman#Hearing_damage
Jason
Excellent review. Words cant describe what its REALLY like 2 see Prince, but u did a great job.
Thanks!
Jason
Jason, you just made me cry…
…and I’m at work!
…It WAS magic wasn’t it!?
Ha ha… :)
Jason
Jason – thank you for this review. It’s amazing to read an article which puts into words what I’ve been unable to since Saturday night. I have never seen a musician so actively engage with his audience. I, too, was blown away by every nod, wink, smile, as he sought out audience members and connected. I’ve never seen anything like it.
Thank you – wasn’t it just amazing! Prince makes each song feel like a meet and greet with each member of the audience.
Jason
thank you for the made-me-feel-like-i-was-there review of this concert! my son Charles Ford was the Lighting Designer for the show, and i am basking in proud mama glow at your mention of his skills in your article!
Hi Cynthia,
That is awesome – I see a lot of lighting, going to many, many concerts, and the show Saturday night was among the best I’ve seen. As a photographer, it made me lament not having an opportunity to take some shots, as it would have been perfect for that, and of course was beautiful for the show. But in addition to that was the timing and orchestration of it all – he really knows his stuff, and was tied into the music as if he were another player on stage, with keen insight into what what happening and the nuance of it all…
You should be very proud, and thanks for writing!
Jason
Great review!!!
We were there as this was my 10th Prince show sine 1995. I’ve seen him up close.. 1998 Key Club with Larry Grahmam and Rosie Gaines…. in 1999 at MGM Grand in Las Vegas… the DNA shows last and multiple arena shows in or around the WestCoast. This was by far the best and most electrifying Prince show I’ve ever seen.
I was in my studio Wed night when I got a text Prince was playing in Oakland.. jumped online and between my GF and I we got 3 tix. We showed up around 3PM and we’re in the Top 40 in line. How about that Flash Mob as well!!!… We joined, learned all the dance movea dn danced our asses off with the other 200 people… such a great time!!!
As soon as we got in we went straight to the front… we were right in front of the piano and little edge were the artists kept coming out. Liz Warfield is OFF THE HOOK!!! yeah she’s not typical but she has soul and a voice to die for… her short set left us in awe and more satisfied then most others full on concert sets!!!
When Prince took the stage with his back to the crowd was a entrance like only Prince can do… he exudes confidence, sex, genius, musicianship, leader more than anyone alive today. There is just no other one like him and can do what he does. My girlfriend is 10 yrs younger then me and didn’t fully “Get It” leading up to the show. She was the typical “yeah he’s cool, kinda weird and HAD a lot of hits on the radio but what is all the hype about?” Well now she GET’S it Big Time!!! By the time the show was over the three of us were exhausted… I honestly didn’t want another encore… I could barely talk, my feet hurt and I was done. Prince took us in, kicked our ass, made us beg for more, gave us more and then some, kicked our ass again and then finally said goodnight.
He’s 55 now and still on top of his game. I tell everyone I know…. go to one of these small intimate shows… just do it and pay the money. He’d great in a arena and all but these are one of a kind shows from the greatest live performer off the last several generations. He’s jimi Hendrix, James Brown, Marvin Gaye, Larry Graham and many more all in one. MJ was the only one close but even the King of Pop couldn’t pull off this type of show. I can now die a happy man!!! haha
PS – It was VERY loud but that’s how IMO it should have been. I respect Ferris’s take but dude… Phil Collins and Prince in the same sentence?!? C’Mon man. Prince is there to rip your head off with classic LOUD blazing Rock n Roll!!! And no.. not a one… person was sitting… from our view when we looked back… that ENTIRE DAMN place was on their feet dancing, clapping and screaming.
CHURCH WAS IN SUCKAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Awesome comments! Yeah, it was definitely a religious experience, for sure! My girlfriend had never seen him before either, and she said afterwards it was the best concert she’s ever seen. I loved seeing her expressions on her face as it first kicked off, as I could live a bit vicariously through her seeing him for the first time. Amazing.
Jason
How wonderful!! And so true!! I had the honour in Sydney, twice. Such an experience. Touching something so deep inside. Healing. Joyful. Learning. Inspiring. Truly living in the moment. Prince gives us something, that cannot be encapsulated or described, something so wonderful, and we are so, so, so grateful.